5 Reasons why User Generated Content Campaigns Fail

After recently posting an article about a Border's User Generated Novel it made me wonder, why do so many user generated content campaigns fail? What should companies be doing to build participation on top of great ideas? How do you leverage social networks?

There are some great examples like the Cadbury Gorilla I blogged about, Dorito's (nice coverage over at Mumbrella), and Tourism Queensland but I opened up the discussion with my fellow Linked In connections about why so many fail and there where some common answers present in many responses.

1. Failure to consider the human element

Above all things, people are time poor with families to feed, jobs to manage and their own dreams to fulfil. Social networks do foster engagement but it's by no means uniform. The level of required participation is a major factor to success.

A combination of a low level work on the participants behalf, with a high level of campaign ownership generally has a good impact on a campaign. Imedia highlight a simple campaign for the release of "Transformers" asking users to submit phrases for Optimum Prime. Visitors to the site voted for the 30 best phrases, and the winning entry appears in the film.

2. An ineffective engagement strategy

Many companies approach social media (and often the net as a whole) as any other traditional advertising channel. A "book this and send it off" mindset which is likely to fail in the social arena. As there is no emphasis on building relationships.

Why would you not want to communicate with the users you are targeting? There needs to be a bond formed between the brand and the participants before users will digg, tweet, bookmark or share a brands campaign.

3. Lack of credibility in the space

Building solid relationships in the space a campaign occupies also plays a massive part in the success of a campaign. Once the relationship is in place (and is a true relationship) then users will feel confident in the brand to “spread” the word and the idea through posts, tweets, conversations etc.



Take for example Skittle's recent foray into social media. A domain mashing up content solely produced by users on Facebook, Twitter, Youtube & Flickr is a gutsy move. But initial responses in marketing circles has been somewhat critical of the implementation of the campaign (See Laurel's Post and Mashable coverage).

4. Failure to empower participants. Engagement + content = ownership

The key here seems to be the ability in gaining the endorsement of a few influential advocates while remainging open to positive and negative discussion.

Perfect example of this is the explosion of wikis and wikipedia the free online encyclopaedia reviewed by users for users. It has changed the way people contribute to discussions, debates and ideas in the social sphere and even in the workplace.

5. A great idea.

Before any of the above can make a difference at the heart of it all needs to be a cracker of an idea that can be easily communicated, is original and compel people to be involved.

Overall, keep it simple, make it worth their while, make it relevant to the brand and most of all don't send it out into the world without a little support.

4 comments:

Offshore Software Development said...

Very interesting.. If these reasons are followed well then I don't think any campaign will fail.

Sophie Amelia said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
lin liyi said...

There is always just about an important gold produced virtually any components and even breitling replica sale which may interact with ones own demand within distinctive bills. Implement rings to create over ones own middle own and unfortunately your note. You may be not surprisingly the things you be dressed in. Running watches divulge that pattern and even qualities on one while not a hot debate and even help you to earn unique acquaintances. Golden contains normally remained well known simply because contain louis vuitton replica, then again silver has grown well liked and even recognised for their mobility and even wearability within cost effective cost. Within the last four years we moreover looked at an enlargement required designed for titanium rings. At present an important womens designer rolex replica uk talks about the. Everything that your lady desires, everything that your lady comes across as being decent on. And also speed settings rolex replica collection will be regardless of you prefer. Be dressed in an important dainty jewel establish golden gold and a powerful armful in clunky rings, that is definitely highly style this holiday season. Running watches comprise of old classic, fashionable, and even green flooring engagement gold design. That option in gemstones to help you countless engagement omega replica sale tends to make an important shiny impression which will honestly allows you to be differentiate yourself. That gem tone includes special appeal to to help you a lot of these design, although clean as a result of each individual engagement honestly shines.

阿童木 said...

Charms series is suitable for various occasions, replica rolex color harmony, echoing Huang Kjin and Malachite diamonds and replica watches other jewelry works by rendering. A family of exquisite jewelry rolex replica series with personal preferences match, especially the new works of Alhambra and Perl watch collocation e series to wear, the effect of perfection. Whether want bold or subtle low-key style, a combination of changes can be accompanied by thousands of times and sparkling.